BLOCKED, WAITING, and TIMED_WAITING are important thread states, but often confusing to many of us. One must have a proper understanding of both in order to analyze thread dumps. Using real-life examples, this article breaks down each state into simpler terms.
Any confusing concepts can be easily understood through examples rather than formal definitions given in Java doc. If they are real-life examples, it can be even more relatable. I would like to share some real-life examples which might help to understand these thread states.
Fig: Transitive Graph generated by http://fastthread.io/ showing which threads are blocking what threads
Java doc formally defines BLOCKED state as: “A thread that is blocked waiting for a monitor lock is in this state.”
Real-life example: Today you are going for a job interview. This is your dream job, which you have been targeting for last few years. You woke up early in the morning, got ready, put on your best outfit, looking sharp in front of the mirror. Now you step out to your garage and realize that your wife has already taken the car. In this scenario, you only have one car, so what will happen? In real life, a fight may happen. However, you are BLOCKED because your wife has already taken the car. You won’t be able to go to the interview.
This is the BLOCKED state. Explaining it in technical terms, you are the thread T1 and your wife is the thread T2 and lock is the car. T1 is BLOCKED on the lock (i.e. the car) because T2 has already acquired this lock.
Titbit: A Thread will enter into BLOCKED state when it’s waiting for a monitor lock to enter a synchronized block/method or reenter a synchronized block/method after calling Object#wait() method.
Java doc formally defines WAITING state as: “A thread that is waiting indefinitely for another thread to perform a particular action is in this state.”
Real-life example: Let’s say a few minutes later your wife comes back home with the car. Now you realize that the interview time is approaching, and there is a long distance to drive to get there. So, you put all the power on the gas pedal in the car. You drive at 100 mph when the allowed speed limit is only 60 mph. Your luck, a traffic cop sees you driving over the speed limit, and he pulls you over to the curb. Now you are entering into the WAITING state, my friend. You stop driving the car and sit idly in the car until the cop investigates you and then lets you go. Basically, until he lets you go, you are stuck in the WAITING state.
Explaining it in technical terms, you are thread T1 and the cop is thread T2. You released your lock (i.e. you stopped driving the car) and went into the WAITING state. Until the cop (i.e. T2) lets you go, you will be stuck in this WAITING state.
Titbit: A Thread will enter into WAITING state when it’s calling one of the following methods:
- Object#wait() with no timeout
- Thread#join() with no timeout
Thread that has called Object.wait() on an object is in WAITING state until another thread to call Object.notify() or Object.notifyAll() on that object. A thread that has called Thread.join() is inWAITING state for a specified thread to terminate.
Java doc formally defines TIMED_WAITING state as: “A thread that is waiting for another thread to perform an action for up to a specified waiting time is in this state.”
Real-life example: Despite all the drama, you did extremely well in the interview, impressed everyone and got this high paying job. (Congratulations!) You come back home and tell your neighbor about this new job and how excited you are about it. Your friend says that he is also working in the same office building. He suggests that the two of you should drive together. You think it’s a great idea. So on the first day of work, you go to his house. You stop your car in front of his house. You wait for 10 minutes, but your neighbor still doesn’t come out. You go ahead and start driving to work, as you don’t want to be delayed on your first day. Now this is TIMED_WAITING.
Explaining it in technical terms, you are thread T1, and your neighbor is thread T2. You release the lock(i.e. stop driving the car) and wait up to 10 minutes. If your neighbor, T2, doesn’t come out in 10 minutes, you start driving the car again.
Titbit: A Thread will enter into TIMED_WAITING state when it’s calling one of the following methods:
- Object#wait() with timeout
- Thread#join() with timeout
When someone is analyzing thread dumps, understanding these different thread states are critical. How many threads are in RUNNABLE, BLOCKED, WAITING, and TIMED_WATING states? Which threads are blocked? Who is blocking them? What object used for locking? These are some of the important metrics to be analyzed in thread dumps. These kinds of detailed thread dump analyses can easily be done through an online tool such as http://fastthread.io/